Guide · Red flags
The most common petroleum trading scams, and the paper trail that exposes them
The TradeNexusMarket team · · Updated · 9 min read
The short answer
Unsolicited offers for EN590 10ppm, Jet A-1, gasoil, fuel oil and crude fill inboxes every day. A share of them are real. A large share are not. The fake ones almost always share one feature: they ask you to pay, sign or hand over sensitive papers before anyone can prove that product exists, that the seller can sell it, and that it will move into your name.
This guide names the patterns buyers meet most often, and the paper trail that exposes each one. It is an umbrella page. Deeper checks for each trap live in their own guides: how to verify an EN590 seller, what a tank storage receipt proves, ATV, ATS and DTA papers, why "MT103 after dip test" is a warning sign and how to verify an SGS or Intertek report.
If an offer uses abbreviations you have not met before, such as ATV, DTA, BCL, "pre-advice MT799" or JP54, look them up in our oil trading glossary before you reply. It says which ones are real documents and which only exist in procedure sheets.
Pattern 1: Storage spoofing and fake tank papers
The classic in-tank scam sells product that is not in the named tank, or a tank that does not exist under that seller. The buyer is shown a "tank storage receipt", a photo of a terminal gate, sometimes a look-alike website for a real storage company, and is then asked to pay for access, rent, injection or a "dip test authorisation".
Rotterdam's public Storage Spoofing task force (Port of Rotterdam Authority, VOTOB, TCT The Commodity Traders and the Seaport Police; site storagespoofing.nl) coined the label for this family of frauds. It publishes a blacklist of suspicious websites that impersonate terminal companies, and states that any deal requiring the buyer to pay for an Authorization to Verify (ATV) or a Dip Test Authorization (DTA) should be considered wrong by definition.
The paper trail that exposes it:
- The terminal confirms the receipt, or it doesn't. A real TSR is issued by the terminal operator. Contact the terminal on details you find yourself from its official site. Never use the phone or email printed on the PDF.
- The storage client matches the SPA party. A receipt in another company's name is not a sale unless the terminal can confirm a transfer chain into the seller.
- The website is the real one. Check the task force blacklist and the company's own domain registration. Look-alike domains that swap one letter are common.
- Dutch operators have a Chamber of Commerce (KVK) number. A "logistics partner" that cannot show a matching registration is not operating as a Dutch company.
Hub pages show what real terminals and transfers look like at EN590 Rotterdam, Fujairah, Singapore and Houston, and for jet at Jet A-1 Rotterdam, Fujairah, Singapore and Houston.
Pattern 2: Fees for ATV, ATS, DTA or "document endorsement"
Many fake procedures wrap the fee inside a permission letter: an ATV so you may "verify" the tank, an ATS so the broker may "sell", a DTA so your inspector may dip. None of those labels is an Incoterms document or a standard terminal form. Our guide to ATV, ATS and DTA explains who can actually authorise anything about a tank: only the company that holds the storage contract, and the terminal that runs it.
The paper trail that exposes it:
- No fee is due to the seller before title moves. Storage rent and inspection costs, when real, are paid to the terminal or the inspector under your own agreement with them, after the SPA says so.
- A permission letter is not proof of product. Ask for a terminal confirmation and an inspector's report you can check with the issuer.
- "Port Authority endorsement" of an ATV or DTA is a known red flag in the Rotterdam task force wording. Port authorities do not endorse private dip tests for buyers in that way.
Pattern 3: "MT103 after dip test"
A dip test shows that a tank holds product at a moment in time. An MT103 is an international wire: once the beneficiary's bank credits the account, the money is very hard to get back. Put payment straight after the dip, before the terminal records a change of holder or loads your vessel, and the buyer has paid in full while still owning nothing. That sequence is walked through in why "MT103 after dip test" is a warning sign.
The paper trail that exposes it:
- Payment trigger in the SPA. Real tank deals usually pay after the terminal's written confirmation that the product is held for the buyer, or against loading documents for a vessel lift. "Payment after injection" is not the same as "payment after dip".
- Your inspector, your report. The report should come to you from the inspection company, and you should confirm it with the issuer.
- No short clock that forces a naked wire. A 24-hour "pay or we release the tank" deadline after a dip is a pressure tactic, not a terminal rule.
Pattern 4: Soft corporate offers with a product menu
A soft corporate offer (SCO) is a normal outline in a real deal. The fake version is a one-page menu: EN590, Jet A-1, gasoil, "D6 virgin" fuel oil, JP54, sometimes urea or LNG, all from the same small company, often on a free-mail address, with huge monthly programmes and a "trial cargo" first. Our guide to what "D6 virgin fuel oil" really is shows how one of those labels is not a grade in any standard.
The paper trail that exposes it:
- One company, one believable product set. A trader that truly holds residual fuel oil, jet and diesel at three hubs at once can name each terminal, tank and title holder. A menu with none of those details cannot.
- Company registry and domain age match the claim. A six-month-old company with a 200,000 MT monthly "programme" is a warning on its own; see the seller checklist.
- Spec sheets name a real edition. "Per ASTM D6" or "Standard Quality and Grade" with round numbers everywhere is typed, not tested.
- Crude "allocations" can be traced. Menus often add Bonny Light with an "NNPC allocation". Our Bonny Light page explains how Nigerian crude is really sold and which export papers a genuine cargo carries. The same goes for "ADNOC allocations": our Murban page sums up ADNOC's own warnings about fake business propositions, and our Basrah Medium page explains why a "SOMO allocation" sold for a fee is not how Iraqi crude is sold.
Pattern 5: Mandate chains, free mail and forged inspection reports
Broker chains of four or five "direct mandates" sit between the buyer and anyone who might hold title. Messages arrive from Gmail or WhatsApp only. The attached "SGS" or "Intertek" PDF uses the wrong office, a look-alike domain, or a report number the issuer will not confirm.
The paper trail that exposes it:
- A signed mandate from the principal, still valid, checked the same way as the seller company itself. What the letter should name, and how to confirm it, is in our seller mandate letter guide.
- Email from the company domain, not a free account claiming to represent it.
- Inspection report verified with the issuer through its official channel. A number alone is not enough; match product, tank or vessel, dates and signatory. See how to verify an SGS or Intertek report.
What a real paper trail looks like
Put the five patterns together and the honest sequence is short. Our LOI, ICPO, SPA and POP guide and Incoterms guide for oil cargoes cover the commercial side; the table below is the verification side.
| Step | What you should hold | Who confirms it |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Registration number, directors, address matching the SPA party | Official company registry of that country |
| Title / storage | Terminal confirmation or TSR naming tank, quantity, holder | The terminal, on contacts you found yourself |
| Quality | Certificate or inspector Q&Q against the named standard edition | The issuing lab or inspector, through its official channel |
| Transfer or load | Terminal transfer confirmation, or bill of lading + load figures | Terminal and/or independent inspector |
| Payment | SPA instrument released against those documents (LC, escrow or wire after transfer) | Your bank and the SPA — not a PDF "MT103 copy" from the seller |
How transfers work in storage deals is covered in TTT vs TTO vs TTV. How to protect payment is in escrow and verification for energy buyers.
Requests that should end the conversation
- Any fee to the seller for a TSR, ATV, DTA, tank rent, injection, notary or "document endorsement" before you hold verified product.
- Full payment by wire straight after a dip test, before the terminal records a change of holder or loads your vessel.
- A procedure that refuses an independent inspector of the buyer's choice, or that routes the report only through the seller.
- Bank details for a personal account, or for a company in a different country from the SPA seller.
- Passport copies, full bank statements or a draft of your MT103 passed along a broker chain before any proof of product is verified.
- Pressure clocks and commission-protection papers (NCNDA / IMFPA) demanded before a single checkable document exists.
None of these is a "local custom". They are the fee-collection and document-harvesting steps the patterns above are built around.
Common questions
Are all soft corporate offers scams? No. An SCO is a normal outline in a real deal. Treat an unsolicited SCO as unverified until the company, the terminal and the documents check out. A multi-product menu from a free-mail address with no tank or title holder is the version to walk away from.
The seller says the terminal will not talk to buyers. Is that true? Many terminals will only discuss a tank with their own client, or with a party the client has authorised in writing. That is normal. What is not normal is a seller who refuses to send that authorisation, or who insists you use only the phone number printed on its PDF. Ask the terminal on contacts from its own website whether the document is theirs.
Can a genuine deal still move quickly? Yes. Speed comes from having the SPA, the inspector and the payment instrument ready, and from the terminal confirming transfer or load. Speed that depends on skipping verification is not a genuine shortcut.
Where do membership rules fit? TradeNexusMarket's membership rules and Deal Room rules set what sellers must show our team before an introduction. They do not replace your own checks once you are in a deal.
Using TradeNexusMarket
Posting a buy or sell requirement is free. Before a Deal Room opens, sellers show our team company papers and a proof of product, and a person on our team checks the files. Posts that pass can carry a POP Approved or POF Approved badge on the public board. No fees are collected for documents or dip tests.
Start with the product pages for EN590 10ppm, Jet A-1, Gasoil D2, Fuel oil and Crude, or create a free account. The membership page explains verification tiers.
General information only, not legal or banking advice. Payment terms are set by your SPA and your bank; confirm terminal procedures with the terminal.
Post free, trade with checked companies
TradeNexusMarket is a B2B marketplace for EN590, Jet A-1, LPG, LNG, crude oil and other fuels. Posting is free and needs no documents. Contacts stay masked, our team makes the match, and both companies are checked before the Deal Room opens. Commission is charged only on a closed deal.
Related reading
- Guide · Deal processOil trading glossary: the deal, bank, storage and shipping terms in plain English
- Guide · EN590How to check whether an EN590 seller is real: a 10-point checklist
- Guide · ComplianceVessel sanctions screening and AIS gaps: the ship checks to run before you sign
- Guide · Red flagsWhy "MT103 after dip test" is a warning sign in fuel offers
- Guide · Deal documentsATV, ATS and DTA: what these storage documents mean, and who can really issue them
- Guide · Deal documentsWhat a TSR (tank storage receipt) is, and how to check one
- Guide · Payment and trustHow escrow, payment instruments and verification protect energy buyers
- Guide · Jet A-1Jet A-1 from refinery to wing: the supply chain and the documents that follow it
- Guide · Crude oilHow to read a crude oil assay for the first time
- Guide · Pricing referencesPlatts and Argus benchmarks explained: CIF NWE, FOB Singapore and FOB Arab Gulf
- Guide · LPG and LNGLPG vs LNG: what a buyer needs to know before asking for a cargo
- Guide · LPGRefrigerated vs pressurised LPG: what changes for a buyer